Performance Boats Forum banner

1 - 20 of 62 Posts

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
1,013 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Another disappointing weekend for us! what I thought was too much oil the last pass I made last month (cause I added 2 extra quarts since I dont run a dip stick and I had an oil leak) was the head gasket on the even side going away and blowing oil out the breather. My boat was running in the pits before I took it over to tech it and it wouldn`t start again. I run a dart block it isnt O ringed and the machining surface on the block/heads has groves not perfectly smooth and I`ve been told the MLS gasket will never work long with that type of machining process. so before I tear this thing down and have it O ringed I want to try the ICS by SCE cooper head gasket. do any of guys have pro`s and con`s about them or the installation process? Keep in mind I`m a union electrician not an engine pro like a lot of you guys but I do all my own stuff and maybe this is the learning curve but I enjoy doing my own stuff and with the hopes of one day setting the world on fire so I can be proud I did it myself and didnt pay a butt load of money to someone else but to be honest, I`m almost there with paying someone else since I`m throwing money away when I head to a race and it doesnt run or just more problems!!!

I brought a leak down tester a few weeks ago and I guess its time to start using it cause I`m sure it would`ve told me something was wrong before I went to the races. I tired to find some in town saturday morning but with the larger bore stuff Bako doesnt have those kinds of speed shops or I didnt find the right place but I thing I call ever where and tried places locals told me to try. Oh well thats racing right? hate that saying

Thanks for the help, Tom
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
25,975 Posts
The early Felpro MLS gaskets had a sticky nitrile coating on them that made them much less sensitive to the deck finish, but now the Felpro has EXACTLY the same coating as the cometics.

But, Mr Gaskets MLS does still have the nitrile coating like the old Felpro. The deck finish is much less critical. So if you still wish the run a MLS, I would consider them.
Any MLS will work better with less than perfect finish if you coat them with some sealers. The GM gasket sealing compound was developed by GM for the Turbo V6 Buick problems and works great, as does Mopar's spray sealer. I wouldn't use it on a Mr.Gasket MLS for the first use, but I have used it for re-using a gasket.
You should be able to get either at any dealership.
Link GM sealer

LINK: Mopar sealer



100% free webcam site! | Awesome chicks and it is absolutely free! | Watch free live sex cam - easy as 1-2-3
 

·
Hoodys and swim trunks
Joined
·
872 Posts
I was always told to use a composite or copper head gasket with o-ringed blocks or heads, not an MLS. These materials yield to the o-ring easier for a better seal. I'd let this thread mature a little before you make any decisions. Lots of guys on here run boosted set-ups that require an o-ring and can point you in the right direction.

What are the current stats on the motor?
 

·
Canoe Jockey
Joined
·
1,130 Posts
well I just went through the crap.....It is not recomended to use a mls gaskets with o-rings. The reason is the process of thermal expansion..the block side layer of a mls gasket is locked by the o-rings and can not move, while the other layers move with thermal expansion. Mls marine gaskets are stainless...o-rings are stainless.....guess what happens..and mls gaskets are not recomended for boost levels above 16psi....its back to copper for me
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
25,975 Posts
I run a dart block it isnt O ringed and the machining surface on the block/heads has groves not perfectly smooth and I`ve been told the MLS gasket will never work long with that type of machining process. so before I tear this thing down and have it O ringed I want to try the ICS by SCE cooper head gasket.

Thanks for the help, Tom
Who said anything about running a MLS and O-rings. I shorten the OP's post so that you 2 could hopefully hang in long enough to get what he was REALLY asking.

Surprised neither of you mentioned that you CANNOT use O-rings with the ICS gasket either.:bangmyhead:



100% free webcam site! | Awesome chicks and it is absolutely free! | Watch free live sex cam - easy as 1-2-3
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
25,975 Posts
well I just went through the crap.....It is not recomended to use a mls gaskets with o-rings. The reason is the process of thermal expansion..the block side layer of a mls gasket is locked by the o-rings and can not move, while the other layers move with thermal expansion. Mls marine gaskets are stainless...o-rings are stainless.....guess what happens..and mls gaskets are not recomended for boost levels above 16psi....its back to copper for me
Is that 16 psi at 12 to 1, or 16 psi at 8 to 1.
I've seen MLS gaskets handle considerably more boost than 16 psi.
But like the OP stated, if the deck finish is not right, they are next to useless. Specially the Cometics and the later Felpros.



100% free webcam site! | Awesome chicks and it is absolutely free! | Watch free live sex cam - easy as 1-2-3
 

·
Canoe Jockey
Joined
·
1,130 Posts
Bob, I see that you are up from your afternoon nap feeling frisky...sorry I can't give you cylinder pressure at those compression figures...I haven't quite figured how to adapt a Keen indicator to a gas engine to give you the bmep figures that you will be asking for.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
25,975 Posts
I wasn't asking for specific cylinder pressures. I was just curious who and how that boost presssure was determined to be the MAX limit for a MLS gasket. I have run 15 psi with a Felpro composite performance gasket before. But then, it wasn't on 12 to 1 alky motor.

The MLS is more than capable of taking just about anybody here can throw at one. Its very seldom the gasket that failed, as much as the person that installed it that failed.



100% free webcam site! | Awesome chicks and it is absolutely free! | Watch free live sex cam - easy as 1-2-3
 

·
Canoe Jockey
Joined
·
1,130 Posts
I see your point...I had spoke to a couple of techs at the manufacture, and the 16 psi number did not come with f/c...But as you posted read the directions that come with your head gaskets...mine had them, but I guess the machine shop could not read the warning in bold letters.
 

·
Distinguished Member
Joined
·
5,772 Posts
Another disappointing weekend for us! what I thought was too much oil the last pass I made last month (cause I added 2 extra quarts since I dont run a dip stick and I had an oil leak) was the head gasket on the even side going away and blowing oil out the breather. My boat was running in the pits before I took it over to tech it and it wouldn`t start again. I run a dart block it isnt O ringed and the machining surface on the block/heads has groves not perfectly smooth and I`ve been told the MLS gasket will never work long with that type of machining process. so before I tear this thing down and have it O ringed I want to try the ICS by SCE cooper head gasket. do any of guys have pro`s and con`s about them or the installation process? Keep in mind I`m a union electrician not an engine pro like a lot of you guys but I do all my own stuff and maybe this is the learning curve but I enjoy doing my own stuff and with the hopes of one day setting the world on fire so I can be proud I did it myself and didnt pay a butt load of money to someone else but to be honest, I`m almost there with paying someone else since I`m throwing money away when I head to a race and it doesnt run or just more problems!!!

I brought a leak down tester a few weeks ago and I guess its time to start using it cause I`m sure it would`ve told me something was wrong before I went to the races. I tired to find some in town saturday morning but with the larger bore stuff Bako doesnt have those kinds of speed shops or I didnt find the right place but I thing I call ever where and tried places locals told me to try. Oh well thats racing right? hate that saying

Thanks for the help, Tom
Tom, man I feel for you bud!! Give me a call and lets see if we can come up with some ideas....

The MLS is more than capable of taking just about anybody here can throw at one. Its very seldom the gasket that failed, as much as the person that installed it that failed.
:))THumbsUp This right here...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,622 Posts
Another disappointing weekend for us! what I thought was too much oil the last pass I made last month (cause I added 2 extra quarts since I dont run a dip stick and I had an oil leak) was the head gasket on the even side going away and blowing oil out the breather. My boat was running in the pits before I took it over to tech it and it wouldn`t start again. I run a dart block it isnt O ringed and the machining surface on the block/heads has groves not perfectly smooth and I`ve been told the MLS gasket will never work long with that type of machining process. so before I tear this thing down and have it O ringed I want to try the ICS by SCE cooper head gasket. do any of guys have pro`s and con`s about them or the installation process? Keep in mind I`m a union electrician not an engine pro like a lot of you guys but I do all my own stuff and maybe this is the learning curve but I enjoy doing my own stuff and with the hopes of one day setting the world on fire so I can be proud I did it myself and didnt pay a butt load of money to someone else but to be honest, I`m almost there with paying someone else since I`m throwing money away when I head to a race and it doesnt run or just more problems!!!

I brought a leak down tester a few weeks ago and I guess its time to start using it cause I`m sure it would`ve told me something was wrong before I went to the races. I tired to find some in town saturday morning but with the larger bore stuff Bako doesnt have those kinds of speed shops or I didnt find the right place but I thing I call ever where and tried places locals told me to try. Oh well thats racing right? hate that saying

Thanks for the help, Tom
O-ring the block and heads, use copper gaskets and forget about it . end of story
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
25,975 Posts
I see your point...I had spoke to a couple of techs at the manufacture, and the 16 psi number did not come with f/c...But as you posted read the directions that come with your head gaskets...mine had them, but I guess the machine shop could not read the warning in bold letters.
I can remember back when running the old shim steel gaskets that having a surfacewith "tooth" was thee setup. Seems many machinists still do. Composite gaskets are a little forgiving for agressively pushed cutters and overly tilted cutter heads. Both will fail a MLS right now! Like I said, the old Felpro and the Mr Gasket will deal with it better than a Cometic, but not by alot.
In the end, any gasket has a much better chance of surviving harsh conditions like a blown deal with hi cylinder pressures if the surface is as dead nuts as you can get it.
I have seen copper and o-rings give guys fits, and others will not use anything but. Personally, if I can avoid them, I do.

I recently bought a set of SCEs with the ICS. I haven't run them yet, but I have heard they work very well in high boost turbo deals. I much perfer to have the O-ring built into the gasket if possible. It seems the guys that run insane boost do as well, or Cometic would have never developed the Phusion series. If you blow one of those, you need to check you studs to see if they stretch as well, or if you still have threads in the block.



100% free webcam site! | Awesome chicks and it is absolutely free! | Watch free live sex cam - easy as 1-2-3
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
1,013 Posts
Discussion Starter #13
First off thank you guys! I was a little taken back when I picked up my stuff and the block wasnt O ring since all my other engines over the years have been but I was told with these dart deals it wasnt really required like when using a chevy block. So before I tear it down and O ring it I`m going to try the ICS SCE gaskets first then if that doesnt work I`m going to tear it down and have it O ringed. I took it apart yesterday and I`m alittle bummed cause the even side of the motor the tops of the pistons have tiny little marks from the missing piece of the head gasket. it doesnt appear it would be a issue but with my current luck it has me wondering if the rods/pistons would like to Hi at some point going down the track.. Nevermind the little piece of blower gasket that blew out and went thru my new blower.. I think what really sucks is I bought a Ron/Joey Grose prop, 55 gallon drum of fuel, hotel rooms, stuff I needed to get my boost up to 20 Ibs, etc.. So this past weekend was a pricey one to say the least even though I needed all this stuff I was really excited to let it rip cause my hopes were set on the low 8`s / high 7`s.... oh well come on May.....Thanks again guys
 

·
steelcomp was here
Joined
·
26,512 Posts
I hear of guys running 30# with Cometics. It's more a bout the flatness of the decks and heads than the finish, but the smoother the better. A lot of head surfacers have the head tilted so the cutter doesn't back-drag, but unfortunately this creates a concave cut across the blocks, and puts the low spot in the absolute worst place...right down the center, between cyl's. Most guys throw a straight edge across the deck from end to end and will tell you it's flat, but never check from top to bottom. Best to check with your machinist and see just how his cutter is set up. A little back drag on the cut doesn't hurt a thing and ensures the cutter is cutting flat. With everything right, I wouldn't hesitate to run the Cometics. I understand that some guys just like O-rings, but that brings with it's own can of worms.
JMO
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,188 Posts
Sorry to hear this Tom.. Definitely sucks!!!

Bob, you keep mentioning the old Fel Pros, does anyone still sell those? I've been running the 1075s.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
3,360 Posts
Talked to Cometic rep at the Napa Drags 2 yrs ago about my twin turbo build and 25+ lbs boost and he actually suggested copper and orings would be better choice.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
25,975 Posts
Sorry to hear this Tom.. Definitely sucks!!!

Bob, you keep mentioning the old Fel Pros, does anyone still sell those? I've been running the 1075s.
The number is the same, the gasket just changed. When the Felpro MLS first came out it was between 2 pieces of slick white paper and a warning not to handle the gasket. Now they are just like the Cometics. Not that that is bad, but the sticky sealer on the Felpros did make the surface prep less critical, mainly smoothness. The Mr. Gasket MLS is very similar to those sticky Felpros. Its not really sticky like the Felpros were, but it definitely a thicker heavier coating than the newer Felpros or Cometics. The newer Felpros and Cometics are almost identicle now.

Like Steelcomp said, the flatness AND CLEANLINESS is probably the most important thing in the prep followed by the surface smoothness.

tkriley, if the ICS gaskets don't do the job for you, then you need to o-ring it. I bought a set myself and they are going in the current build. We'll both put them to the test. But I feel pretty confident they will be fine. And they are a little less than the Cometics, and I can see any reason they can't be reused with a little sealer.

O rings work, but they are a PIA, and anybody that tells you they never had a water leak with them is probably lying. They work, and they suck



100% free webcam site! | Awesome chicks and it is absolutely free! | Watch free live sex cam - easy as 1-2-3
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,188 Posts
Bob, that's exactly how they came the last time I ordered them. Guess that has changed in last year or so? So you would go th with the Mr gasket route instead of the 1075s?
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
25,975 Posts
Bob, that's exactly how they came the last time I ordered them. Guess that has changed in last year or so? So you would go th with the Mr gasket route instead of the 1075s?
Yeah, if your looking for the sticky like sealer, the Mr Gasket is much closer to older Felpros. I am running a set right now and they have been fine so far. I would personally would buy them again. A tad cheaper than Cometics or felpro.



100% free webcam site! | Awesome chicks and it is absolutely free! | Watch free live sex cam - easy as 1-2-3
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,622 Posts
The number is the same, the gasket just changed. When the Felpro MLS first came out it was between 2 pieces of slick white paper and a warning not to handle the gasket. Now they are just like the Cometics. Not that that is bad, but the sticky sealer on the Felpros did make the surface prep less critical, mainly smoothness. The Mr. Gasket MLS is very similar to those sticky Felpros. Its not really sticky like the Felpros were, but it definitely a thicker heavier coating than the newer Felpros or Cometics. The newer Felpros and Cometics are almost identicle now.

Like Steelcomp said, the flatness AND CLEANLINESS is probably the most important thing in the prep followed by the surface smoothness.

tkriley, if the ICS gaskets don't do the job for you, then you need to o-ring it. I bought a set myself and they are going in the current build. We'll both put them to the test. But I feel pretty confident they will be fine. And they are a little less than the Cometics, and I can see any reason they can't be reused with a little sealer.

O rings work, but they are a PIA, and anybody that tells you they never had a water leak with them is probably lying. They work, and they suck
If sealed properly you will never have a water leak. I haven't had one leak in over 20 years. the first set I put on leaked like crazy and that was the last one that ever leaked Ronny Sproll showed me the deal many years ago. I was at a race in Decator, Ill. and fixed it on Sunday morning.Head has less chance of moving with a O ring head and block. All my engines are O=ringed and I never blew a head gasket either.
 
1 - 20 of 62 Posts
Top