Performance Boats Forum banner
1 - 20 of 32 Posts

· The Pool Bitch
Joined
·
4,150 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
California senator gets tough on BUI
Bill would take away offenders’ licenses

By David Bell
Sunday, June 28, 2009 9:35 PM MST


A California state senator wants drunken boaters to lose their license to drive their automobiles.

Sen. John J. Benoit, R-Bermuda Dunes, introduced SB 154, which would reinstate the suspension of California driver’s license for individuals convicted of boating under the influence.

“Havasu spent eight years in DUI enforcement, making over 1,000 arrests. I have witnessed how the bad choices made under the influence of alcohol have created countless tragedies. My legislation reflects the seriousness of BUI offenses, protecting the safety of travelers on California’s streets, highways and waterways,” Benoit said in a press release.

Starting the in the mid-1990s, the California Department of Motor Vehicles suspended licenses for BUI convictions, but that procedure was ordered stopped by the California Court of Appeals in 2008, citing the lack of statutory authority.

The bill calls for the DMV to suspend the license of anyone convicted with a prior DUI or BUI conviction. It would also require that anyone convicted of boating under the influence attend and complete an alcohol education course.

According to the California Department of Boating and Waterways, about 25 percent of all deaths on California waterways are attributed to impaired vessel operators. And of the 55 boating fatalities in 2007, that number of alcohol-related deaths climbed to just under half.

Benoit was a 31-year veteran of law enforcement before moving into politics. He worked with the Corona Police Department before joining California Highway Patrol in 1971. His district includes Riverside County, which borders the Colorado River.

The California State Sheriff’s Association, District Attorneys Association, Boating Safety Officers Association and other water-based organizations have formally supported the bill.

Although the San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Office has not taken a formal position on the bill, SBCSO Sgt. Tim Smith, who heads the marine division for the Needles station, said, “We’ll support it. It’s a win-win,” in reducing the number of impaired boaters.

The bill was passed by the state Senate on May 26 and received unanimous support in the Assembly Committee on Public Safety on June 23. It now awaits action by the full Assembly.
 

· Colts fan & Stoker owner
Joined
·
7,834 Posts
Like everything, there is a time and a place for it.


I like it! I do drink but NEVER when driving or boating! There's plenty of time to get your drink on in the evening when your return from the lake!!!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,286 Posts
This is the greatest news, more laws normally fries my ass, but this is good stuff, take away the boat for 6 months, fantasti9c, hopefully they pass it, and more important..ENFORCE it!!!

There is another forum that wont agree with this new law...we will have to see!!
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
355 Posts
Accident in HB Harbor, possible BUI, 2 Dead, one ?

This is the greatest news, more laws normally fries my ass, but this is good stuff, take away the boat for 6 months, fantasti9c, hopefully they pass it, and more important..ENFORCE it!!!

There is another forum that wont agree with this new law...we will have to see!!
After this Fridays or Sat morning 0130 accident, in HB Harbor, 3 subjects on a 12' inflatable tried to go under the Gilbert Bridge at high speed. Two were decapitated, one critical, not official yet, but sounds like another sad BUI accident. And thats a 20 HP motor! I think most of us have a little more! Feel real bad for their families, what a senseless loss!
 

· Old Skool Member
Joined
·
6,086 Posts
I disagree with it simply because you don't need a license to drive a boat so why lose your drivers license which has nothing to do with it.

Now, if you want to license boat drivers and tie it to your current drivers license (like a motorcycle endorsement) then I would be OK with that.

Other than that have at it.........
 

· Lavey Me Alone
Joined
·
1,404 Posts
I disagree with it simply because you don't need a license to drive a boat so why lose your drivers license which has nothing to do with it.

Now, if you want to license boat drivers and tie it to your current drivers license (like a motorcycle endorsement) then I would be OK with that.

Other than that have at it.........
This is my feeling as well.
 

· "Try it Now!"
Joined
·
3,614 Posts
This is the greatest news, more laws normally fries my ass, but this is good stuff, take away the boat for 6 months, fantasti9c, hopefully they pass it, and more important..ENFORCE it!!!

There is another forum that wont agree with this new law...we will have to see!!
Take away a boat for 6 months, but a dui driver in a car can get his vehicle the very next day..that doesn't make a whole lot of sense. DUI's on the highway outnumber BUI's 1000's of times to one.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
6,017 Posts
I disagree with it simply because you don't need a license to drive a boat so why lose your drivers license which has nothing to do with it.

Now, if you want to license boat drivers and tie it to your current drivers license (like a motorcycle endorsement) then I would be OK with that.

Other than that have at it.........
And you have had to have a prior DUI/BUI to lose your DL.

A quote from Phebus post.....

The bill calls for the DMV to suspend the license of anyone convicted with a prior DUI or BUI conviction. It would also require that anyone convicted of boating under the influence attend and complete an alcohol education course.
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
355 Posts
I disagree with it simply because you don't need a license to drive a boat so why lose your drivers license which has nothing to do with it.

Now, if you want to license boat drivers and tie it to your current drivers license (like a motorcycle endorsement) then I would be OK with that.

Other than that have at it.........
Without agreeing or disagreeing, in California driving is considered a "privilege" by law makers and not a "right". There is already is a list of reasons non driving related that you can lose your license, just don't pay your child support, medical, etc..... sounds like California is just "adding" to the list?
 

· Old Skool Member
Joined
·
6,086 Posts
I agree with this, however there are currently other things that will take away your DL, that has nothing really to do with driving. IE child support/dss stuff, insurance canellation, etc.
Without agreeing or disagreeing, in California driving is considered a "privilege" by law makers and not a "right". There is already is a list of reasons non driving related that you can lose your license, just don't pay your child support, medical, etc..... sounds like California is just "adding" to the list?
Well, I am considered a AZ resident and CA is out of control as it is and this would not even have a bearing on me regardless. I don't know all that applies to take a lic away but the insurance stuff is directly tied into your lic as it is mandatory. The child support and whatever else is attached to it is where the debating could come into it.

Just more red tape BS......

And you have had to have a prior DUI/BUI to lose your DL.

A quote from Phebus post.....

The bill calls for the DMV to suspend the license of anyone convicted with a prior DUI or BUI conviction. It would also require that anyone convicted of boating under the influence attend and complete an alcohol education course.
Regardless.....make a boat lic manadatory and then take it away on the first offense. Very few of us make a living by driving a boat. The majority of us can't make a living without our drivers lic. Taking a drivers lic away because of driving a boat which isn't as important to 99.9% of us out there just doesn't make sense to me.
 

· DRIVE4SHOW-PUTT4$$$
Joined
·
643 Posts
Question

after a dui the dmv suspends your lic.so you cant drive a car, but you can still drive a boat.:mad: IM all for getting the drunks off the water and roads!!! so it should work both ways...........get a dui or bui you should lose all rights for driving and boating!!!
my question is, can you still operate a water vessel after a BUI ?
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,554 Posts
The professional operators I know are smart enough to know not to drink and drive while off duty as it might affect their method of making a living.....:)bulb

I fail to see if how someone who is BUI is any different than a DUI. If someone dies as a result of BUI they are still Dead.

BUI is negligent operation and the driver should be punished.

Regardless.....make a boat lic manadatory and then take it away on the first offense. Very few of us make a living by driving a boat. The majority of us can't make a living without our drivers lic. Taking a drivers lic away because of driving a boat which isn't as important to 99.9% of us out there just doesn't make sense to me.
 

· Old Skool Member
Joined
·
6,086 Posts
after a dui the dmv suspends your lic.so you cant drive a car, but you can still drive a boat.:mad: IM all for getting the drunks off the water and roads!!! so it should work both ways...........get a dui or bui you should lose all rights for driving and boating!!!
my question is, can you still operate a water vessel after a BUI ?
Yep!
 
1 - 20 of 32 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top